ACROSS
1 Type of boat lodged in Niagara Falls for more than 100 years
5 Rapper's rhythmic pattern
9 Gem with a play of color
13 Hedging words in an estimate
14 Big game venue
15 Fancy fabric spelled with the same consonants as "limo"
16 "Midnite Vultures" singer-songwriter
17 Perfect pair
19 Word before "lettuce" or "cucumber"
20 "For real?"
21 Moralistic types
23 Drink like a cat
24 British bathroom
25 Shows excess concern
26 Room littered with dirty clothes, e.g.
27 Sleep disorder
28 Able to be tried
29 Edge of a hat
33 Made with more than just Nestle Toll House chips, say
36 Certain gender-fluid person, for short
37 Where insults are said to stick
38 Voltaire, religiously
39 One might be personal or technical
40 Talks immodestly
41 Donkey
44 Korean American actor Philip
45 Forum regular who doesn't post messages
46 Damage control experts
49 Not trans
51 Prime time?
52 Apiece
53 A single time
54 Vowels in "Old MacDonald"
55 Site such as Fandom
56 Wetland growth
57 Not as much
58 Singer born Eithne Padraigin Ni Bhraonain
DOWN
1 Weeps
2 Furtively approach
3 Academy slight
4 Moo goo gai pan pan
5 Worries
6 Remini of "The King of Queens"
7 Product line?
8 "Hold on!"
9 Minnesota's St. ___ College
10 Like the Holy See
11 BP subsidiary
12 Resulted in
14 Vaulted recesses of churches
18 They should last 10-20 minutes, per many sleep experts
20 Perfect
22 Lead-in to a cooking date?
25 Become dim
26 Taj ___
28 Certain ponytail holder
29 Dreary
30 Create a disturbance
31 "Hard to know what to do"
32 Citi Field players
34 Lodging that may be LEED-certified
35 Noble gases lack them
39 Beanie Babies and Wordle, for two
40 Southwestern pack animal
41 In regard to
42 Book title spot
43 "Well, ___ you asked ..."
45 Designer Vuitton
47 Have to have
48 "Little piggies"
50 Twelvers' Islamic branch
52 Lamb's mom